https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrNMc0VTDUA&t=4579s
I recently watched the debate between David Wood and Mohammed Hijab about Trinity vs. Tawheed. A lot of arguments were raised by both sides but I want to deal with an argument that Mohammed Hijab presented. He presented a good argument and I believe it was a valid argument. Wood answered this but I don’t think his answer quite did the argument justice.
There was a recent debate between Adnan Rashid and Samuel Green on salvation in Christianity and Islam. Samuel Green was technically representing the Christian side, though Green isn’t a Catholic so his theology is somewhat off though obviously closer to my position than the position of Adnan Rashid.
Sacred Scripture
If you’ve ever had dialogue with a Muslim on religion, you’ll find out very quickly that he believes that the previous Scriptures are corrupted and unreliable. Sometime before the Quran was revealed the Scriptures got corrupted. Where and when did they get corrupted? If you ask five different Muslims, you’re likely to get five different answers, unless they tell you that they don’t know. The interesting thing is to look in the holy book and see what it says.
I’m a huge fan of Steve Ray. He’s a very good apologist, especially when it comes to the early Church fathers. I’ve read several of his books including his book on his conversion story and his evaluation of the Papacy. Here he is at Franciscan University of Steubenville talking about Islam. For those who don’t know FUS is one of the biggest Catholic education centres in America so this isn’t some minor audience. It’s a group of University students at a Catholic University. The talk is also recorded and put on the Steubenville YouTube channel so it’s a huge Catholic audience.
Jesus and Mary in Islamic art
According to Muslim tradition, when Muhammad was 40 years old, he was spoken to by an angel and this made him a prophet. For the next 23 years of his life, he would receive more of the Quran until he had received it all. If one were to talk to Muhammad when he was 30, he would not have claimed to be a prophet of God. What made him a prophet? The Quran.
Christ the King
When reading the Gospels, we see that Jesus Christ made great claims about himself. He referred to himself as many things but the question is, did he claim to be the Prophet like Moses in Deuteronomy 18? Muslims like to point to Muhammad and say that he is the Prophet of Deuteronomy 18. The truth is, when we look at the words of Christ and His apostles, there is no way that this passage could refer to Muhammad, Joseph Smith, or Mirza Ghulam Ahmad. If anyone professes to believe in Christ, you have to follow what He says; so what does He say about this issue?
The first time I encountered Faiz online I thought he was an atheist. This is because of the double standards that he uses. For example, he keeps saying that we have no first century manuscripts of the NT. He’s correct, we don’t. No first century book or document has first century manuscripts.
Muslims and Christians both agree that Jesus Christ is the Messiah. Where we disagree is on the status of Muhammad in the Abraham tradition. Muslims believe that he was the seal of the prophets, and Christians claim that he was a pretender, no different than Joseph Smith or Mirza Ghulam Ahmad. One big problem for this claim was that he never confronted the religious authorities on this.
Dhul Qarnayn – Alexander the Great
When one studies ancient history, we see that the Greeks and the Persians were always at war, similar to how the English and French were always at war during the Middle Ages. This happened from about 500 BC to the the Arab Conquest of Persia in the 7th Century.
Things have become worse in the situation between the Russian Orthodox Church and the Greek Orthodox Church of Constantinople. In the interview above(which is short and I recommend everyone watch), the Orthodox bishop says that Russians who go on vacation in Turkey cannot receive communion in the churches there. This is a pretty serious situation.