In defending the doctrine of the Trinity against Islam or another heretical group, there are several resources that I recommend. There are actually five sources that I recommend but the fifth one is the Bible so it’s a given. One needs to know the Bible in order to defend the Trinity, or any other doctrine for that matter. Of my four additional sources that I’m going to recommend, two are from the ancient church and two are from modern apologists.
The first document to consider is the Nicene-Constantinople Creed itself. This is the product of two fourth century councils. Almost every phrase in the document comes straight from the Bible and that just goes to show how seriously these men took scripture. It also shows what I said before in that the first thing one needs to know is the Bible.
The second document is the book On the Trinity by St. Augustine of Hippo. Reading this book will allow you to familiarize yourself with how top bishops in the early Church defended this doctrine. Reading literature like this helps one get into a Trinitarian mindset instead of memorizing the Creed or proof texts from the Bible.
Now, these two ancient sources aren’t that early. They’re from the fourth and fifth centuries which doesn’t provide an early witness. If one wants to prove the Trinity from ancient witnesses, it’s better to look at the second century fathers like St. Ignatius of Antioch and others. Although early witnesses are important, they’re not important enough to make it into the top four resources that I’m recommending.
The third source and the first of our two modern documents is The Forgotten Trinity by Dr. James White. I love this book. White is an expert in apologetics and the Greek language. He’s defended the deity of Christ many times in debate. His book doesn’t only give good texts that prove the Trinity but he also shows the important roles of the three persons of the Trinity. For example, he goes deep into texts like John 1 and shows the deep theology of the prologue of the Gospel.
The last of the documents is the book that I recently reviewed. It’s the book Our God is Triune. The book isn’t written by one author. It’s a collection of essays written by apologists and scholars who have been studying this doctrine for many years. Although the book is simply about the Trinity, it is geared toward Islamic polemics. Vocab Malone and Anthony Rogers are two of the contributors and they deal very extensively with Islamic apologetics. This book is very advanced so it should be the last to be read out of these four documents.
These are the four sources that I would recommend. I would recommend reading them in this order as well. Obviously if one is getting into apologetics, they’ll have to read even more than this, but these sources are the bare minimum. They’re a good starting point. In previous posts, I’ve often talked about how Muslims should be forced to give an answer to their Quran utterly collapsing on the doctrine of the Trinity. This is true and that’s an avenue one can go down. However, at the end of the day, we need to know how to defend the doctrine as well. After all, even if Islam and the Quran are false, it doesn’t mean that the Trinity is true. We need to be able to articulate it well and these four sources are the place to start.
You MUST read Dr. Robert A. Morey’s The Trinity: Evidence and Issues. That is the one book that influenced me the most, followed by White’s book. Though there are lots of typos and some mistakes in some of the things he says, it is by far the best book out there in my view.
Hi Sam,
I must make a confession. I’ve never read anything by Dr. Morey. Would you say that there is stuff in Morey’s book that you cannot find in The Forgotten Trinity or Our God is Triune? If there is I’ll definitely pick it up.
Btw, great livestream yesterday!
God bless
Allan
Robert Letham’s “The Holy Trinity” is excellent and has a lot more information from the early church fathers and creeds and church history.
John Piper’s Introduction and chapter on Athanasius in his book “Contending for Our All” is worth the whole book.
His lecture on his life and impact is free at desiringGod.org.
https://www.desiringgod.org/messages/contending-for-our-all
Piper demonstrates that Athanasius taught us on the issues of the Deity of Christ and the Trinity, we need theological language that communicates what the Bible is teaching, even though the words used to interpret what the Bible teaches, the Bible does not use the exact words – like Trinity, homo-ousias. (and many other examples)
I’ve read Letham. He’s good. Never read that Piper book though. I suppose I could check out the lecture due to it being free.
The more I read though Spencer Stewart’s The Preeminence of Christ: Part Two, the more I am impressed. It covers several passages that were not highlighted in Our God is Triune.
I will look into this.